The Niche Shop’s Guide to New York City’s Best Holiday Markets
The season of giving (and thrifting) is here, and we’re making our lists, checking them twice, and heading straight to the best NYC markets. Whether you’re shopping for your vintage-loving bestie, your cool aunt, or a little something for yourself, New York has no shortage of unique, handmade, and secondhand treasures. Here’s where you’ll find us this holiday season — cocoa in hand and tote bag at the ready.
Part Two — The Luxury Edit
December 5-7 | 477 Broadway
Part Two Luxury Market is coming back for another season. Keep an eye out for this curated market happening December 5th - December 7th and experience bringing together vintage luxury, independent jewelry designers, and high-end resellers. It’s a go-to for elevated gifting — think vintage designer bags, chic leather jackets, and timeless accessories.
Perfect for: treating yourself to something on your wishlist. Get your tickets now! Use code THENICHESHOP for 10% off your ticket.
Grand Bazaar NYC — Upper West Side
Every Sunday | 100 W 77th St
A Niche favorite (it’s just a few blocks from our UWS shop!), this market has everything from vintage coats to handmade jewelry. It’s the perfect mix of local artisans, vintage vendors, and holiday spirit — plus, every purchase supports local schools. We’ll be there December 7th and 14th from 10 am - 5 pm.
Pro tip: Stop by early for the best finds, then swing by The Niche Shop to finish your gift list.
Not-A-Normal Market — Holiday Edition
December 5-7 & December 12-14 | 6th Ave. and 33rd St.
For those who love fashion and vintage designer, the Not-A-Normal Market is the place to shop this season. Expect vintage vendors (including us 👀), sustainable brands, and statement pieces you won’t find anywhere else.
Insider Tip: Grab your tickets early for the VIP first look and come find us — we’ll be there both weekends. December 5th - 7th and 12th - 14th.
Chelsea Flea Market
Saturdays & Sundays | 29 W 25th St
A true NYC treasure — vintage clothing, furniture, and one-of-a-kind collectibles. It’s the perfect place to find that “how did you even find this?” kind of gift.
For the vintage maximalist: hunt for antique jewelry or mid-century home decor pieces for that special someone in your life.
Renegade Craft Fair
December 13–14 | Metropolitan Pavilion, 125 W 18th St
The Renegade Craft Fair is a handmade heaven — over a hundred independent makers, artists, and designers all in one place. From small-batch candles to funky ceramics, it’s a dream stop for anyone who loves shopping small and supporting artists. There is also one in Brooklyn the weekend before!
Good for: stocking stuffers, creative gifts, and self-care finds.
Columbus Circle Holiday Market
November 28–December 31 | 59th St & Central Park West
A true holiday classic — think twinkling lights, hot chocolate, and rows of festive booths filled with artisan-made jewelry, cozy accessories, and international treats.
Bonus: After shopping, take a winter walk through Central Park (preferably with a pretzel in hand).
Union Square Holiday Market
November 21–December 24 | Union Square Park
Another must-visit, this market is home to 150+ vendors offering everything from hand-knit scarves to custom prints. It’s the kind of place you’ll leave with more gifts than you planned — and a cinnamon donut for the walk home.
Essex Market
Daily | 88 Essex St
For the foodie on your list, Essex Market is a Lower East Side staple. While it’s open year-round, it’s especially magical in winter — packed with local vendors selling specialty foods, coffee, and artisanal treats.
Perfect for: creating your own NYC-made holiday basket.
From holiday markets to year-round vintage gems, there’s no better place than NYC to find gifts with character. Shop local, shop secondhand, and give something that they will love!